It is remarkable how quickly a piece of information can travel and how slowly we sometimes arrive at the truth. A message appears on our phones, a video is shared in a group, someone claims to know what has happened, and within minutes the information has reached people who have no way of knowing whether it is true. Before long, people are discussing it, interpreting it, adding their own explanations and passing it on to others. By the time someone thinks of asking where it came from, the story may already have travelled further than anyone can trace.
We live in an age in which information is abundant, but certainty is not. We can know about an event almost as soon as it happens, yet knowing that something has happened is not the same as understanding what happened. We receive fragments, accounts, opinions and versions, often from people we trust, and are expected to make sense of them while the next piece of information is already arriving. It is almost as though we have become so accustomed to receiving information that we have forgotten the need to sit with it for a while, to examine it, and sometimes to admit that we do not yet know enough.
Perhaps that is one of the reasons rumours have become such a powerful part of our lives. They fit neatly into the gaps between what we know and what we want to know. When the facts are incomplete, a rumour offers an explanation. When an event leaves us confused, it gives us a story. And when we are already worried about something or someone, it can provide the confirmation we have been looking for, even when there is little evidence to support it.
But rumours are not new. Long before the arrival of smartphones and social media, stories travelled through neighbourhoods, marketplaces, gatherings and conversations. A remark was repeated, an account was embellished, an assumption became an allegation, and before long people were speaking about something as though they knew it to be true. Technology has changed the speed, reach and permanence of these stories, but it has not created the human tendency to believe them. That tendency was already there, waiting for a more efficient means of travel.
What is perhaps more difficult to understand is why we continue to fall for rumours when we know how unreliable they can be. We are a species that takes considerable pride in its intelligence. We have learnt to question nature, explore space, develop medicines, build complex systems and make sense of things that once seemed impossible to understand. Yet, when an unverified message reaches us, we can sometimes abandon the very habits of thought that have brought us this far. We believe first and question later, if we question at all.
There is an uncomfortable contradiction here. We know that information can be misleading, that photographs can be taken out of context, that videos can be edited and that people can deliberately distort events. We know that a story changes as it passes from one person to another. Yet we often behave as though these possibilities apply to everyone else’s information except the information we receive from people we trust.
Perhaps the problem is not that we lack the ability to think, but that we do not always want to think carefully when something already agrees with us.
When a piece of information confirms what we suspect, we are often willing to accept it with very little resistance. When it challenges what we believe, we become more demanding. We ask for proof, question the source and look for reasons to dismiss it. We may convince ourselves that we are being discerning, when all we are really doing is applying different standards to different versions of a story. The truth becomes secondary to whether the information makes sense to us, whether it comes from someone we trust, or whether it supports the position we have already taken.
This is where rumours find their strength. They do not always need to persuade us of something entirely new. Often, they only need to reinforce what we already suspect.
In my earlier reflections on not talking and the problem of suspicion, I have been thinking about what happens when we lose the willingness to speak to one another, especially when we disagree. When conversations become difficult, we withdraw. When we no longer feel comfortable asking questions, we begin to make our own assumptions. And when those assumptions are left unexamined, suspicion begins to occupy the space where understanding might once have grown.
Rumours enter that space rather easily.
When we are no longer talking to one another, we lose the simplest means of checking what we hear. We cannot ask for an explanation if we have already decided that the other person has nothing worth telling us. We cannot correct a misunderstanding if we are unwilling to have the conversation that might expose it. Instead, we begin to depend on what others tell us about one another, and the people who tell us these stories may be just as uncertain as we are.
The difficulty is that we rarely treat all uncertainty equally. A story that confirms our suspicions can seem entirely believable, while a straightforward explanation from the person concerned may be dismissed as an excuse. We may not have spoken to the person, examined the evidence or heard the other account, but we have already reached a conclusion. In this way, a rumour can do what an actual conversation might have prevented: it can turn a question into a judgement before the facts have had a chance to emerge.
And once a rumour has been accepted, it does not always remain a rumour in our minds. We begin to remember it as something that happened, refer to it in later conversations and use it to explain other things we see or hear. Each repetition gives it another layer of familiarity. Eventually, we may no longer remember who first told us the story, or whether anyone ever established its truth. We simply remember that we have heard it many times.
Repetition, however, is not evidence. A story does not become true because it is familiar, any more than an allegation becomes a fact because enough people have repeated it. Yet familiarity can make us less likely to question something, particularly when it has become part of the way we understand a person or a situation.
This is not merely a problem of individuals being careless with messages on their phones. It is a problem that grows within the relationships we have with one another. The information we choose to believe is often shaped by the people we trust, the groups to which we belong and the fears we carry. When trust is strong, we may be willing to ask questions and accept explanations. When trust is broken, even a genuine explanation can appear suspicious. The same information can be received very differently depending on who shares it, who is discussed in it and what we already believe about the people involved.
In Manipur, we have particular reason to think carefully about this. We know that information does not travel through a neutral space. It travels through communities, relationships, histories, fears and loyalties. People hear different accounts of events, sometimes with very different explanations of what has happened and why. A claim that is uncertain in one place may be accepted as fact in another. A video without sufficient context may be treated as proof, while an attempt to correct the account may be dismissed because of who made it.
The danger is not simply that people may believe something false. It is that an unverified story can reinforce a suspicion that was already there, deepen an existing mistrust and influence how people respond to one another. A rumour can travel far beyond the person who first shared it, and its consequences can remain long after the original claim has been questioned or disproved.
We should also be careful not to assume that everyone who passes on a rumour intends to cause harm. Some do, of course. But many people share information because they are worried, because they believe others should know, or because they think they are helping to protect the people around them. They may have received the message from someone they trust and assume that the necessary checks have already been made. The intention may be entirely sincere, but sincerity does not establish the truth of a claim.
We have become very efficient at sharing information. A few taps are enough to send a message to dozens of people, and a few more can carry it much further. But how much thought do we give to the responsibility that comes with this ability? We have learnt to use the tools of communication, but we have not necessarily learnt to examine what passes through them. We may know how to forward a video without knowing how to establish when it was recorded, where it came from or whether it shows what the accompanying message claims it shows.
The sheer volume of information makes this more difficult. We cannot investigate everything, nor should we imagine that we can. But perhaps we need to recognise the difference between being informed and being overwhelmed. When too much information arrives too quickly, we may begin to depend on familiar voices and ready-made explanations rather than making the effort to distinguish what is known from what is assumed. We may even mistake the confidence with which someone speaks for the reliability of what they are saying.
The answer cannot be to distrust everything we hear. A society in which every account is automatically suspected would be no better off than one in which every claim is accepted without question. We need one another to communicate, to share what we know and to help make sense of events. But we also need the patience to recognise that not everything we hear is established fact, and that sometimes the most honest response is to say we do not yet know.
There is a particular kind of discomfort in leaving a question unanswered. We want to know what happened, who was responsible and what it means. We want to form an opinion and move on. Yet there are times when the facts are incomplete, when accounts contradict one another, and when a little more patience would serve us better than an immediate conclusion. We must learn to live with that uncertainty without rushing to fill it with whatever explanation happens to reach us first.
This is not always easy, especially when a rumour touches something we care deeply about. When it concerns our community, our leaders, our identity or our understanding of past events, we may feel that accepting or rejecting the claim is itself a statement of loyalty. We may fear that questioning a story will be interpreted as taking the other side, or that withholding judgement will make us appear indifferent. But truth cannot depend on which side we believe ourselves to be standing on. If we are willing to question a claim when it comes from someone we distrust, we must be equally willing to question it when it comes from someone we trust.
Perhaps this is where the problem of rumours connects to so many of the other difficulties we face. The stories we accept can influence the leaders we admire or condemn, the memories we preserve, the identities we defend and the anger we carry. They can shape our understanding of who has wronged us, who deserves our trust and who should be held responsible. A rumour may begin as a few words passed from one person to another, but in a society already burdened by suspicion, those words can become part of a much larger story about ourselves and the people around us.
And once that story takes hold, it becomes harder to return to the beginning and ask what we actually know. We may defend our version of events because we have repeated it so often, or because too much of our understanding now depends on it. We may find it easier to blame those who spread rumours than to acknowledge the part we have played in giving them credibility. The possibility that we have been mistaken can be difficult to accept, particularly when our beliefs have become entangled with our sense of belonging.
I do not think any of us is entirely immune to this. We can be careful and still be misled. We can have good intentions and still pass on something that turns out to be false. The point is not to pretend that we will never make mistakes, but to recognise the responsibility we carry when we share information about other people and events that affect us all. There must be room for us to correct ourselves, to reconsider what we have believed and to acknowledge when the evidence does not support the story we accepted.
Perhaps our intelligence is not measured only by how quickly we understand something, but also by our ability to recognise when we have not understood enough. There is no shame in waiting for more information, asking a question or changing our minds. What should concern us is the ease with which we sometimes allow a rumour to do our thinking for us.
We cannot prevent every rumour from beginning, and we cannot always know the truth immediately. But we can decide whether we will help an unverified story travel further. We can pause before forwarding a message, question a claim that seems designed to provoke an immediate reaction, and resist the temptation to treat what confirms our suspicions as proof. These are small acts, but they matter because rumours depend not only on the person who starts them, but also on all those who allow them to travel.
And perhaps we should remember where this chain of problems begins. When we stop talking, we make room for suspicion. When suspicion grows, rumours find people ready to believe them. And when rumours become part of what we accept as truth, the distance between us grows a little wider. We become more certain about people we have not spoken to, more convinced of stories we have not verified, and less willing to have the conversations that might help us understand one another.
The question, then, is not only why people spread rumours. It is why we are so willing to believe them, and what we are prepared to do with the information we receive. We may not be able to control every story that reaches us, but we can choose not to become its next carrier simply because it confirms what we already think.
Sometimes, before we decide what to believe about one another, we may need to find the courage to ask, to listen, and to talk again.

Sam Khumanthem writes about home, identity, and the quiet complexities of life in Manipur. His work reflects a deep connection to place, shaped by both love and uncertainty.




