It is a truism that human aspirations and conditions, like everything else, are very much moving targets. What one generation conceived as their prized collective goal, hated adversary or trusted ally, may not remain so for the generations that follow them. In fact, they seldom do.
Often however, especially indigenous societies, of which most in the Northeast are, refuse to acknowledge this, trapping themselves in peculiar time warps.
In the real world they may have moved on, but mentally, they often allow themselves to remain caught in eras several decades gone, departure points from which are etched in their collective memory by pivotal historical events.
This is the broad profile of the region’s grapple with modernity, brought in by the British administration first and refined and democratised by independent India. This dilemma is quite reminiscent of the iconic Nigerian writer Chinua Achebe’s Things Fall Apart where he conceptualises the agonising dilemma indigenous African communities faced at the advent of modernity represented by the arrival and spread of Christianity.
Without doubt the new world brought with it dividends in terms of education, health, wealth and science among others, but it also replaced old familiar ways of life and their entrenched values.
Much of the problems of ethnic unrests Northeast witnessed today have this at its roots too. The resistance against replacing customary land laws with modern land revenue administration, or even violent clashes over claims of primacy of one tribe’s customary law over that of others in a multiethnic geography, are just some examples of this complex maze of conflict scenarios.
Manipur is where this dynamics is playing out most prominently, but nobody in the Northeast will have a doubt that similar fault-lines lie dormant as frozen conflicts with fuses still intact practically in every Northeast state.
While change is inevitable, as Nari Rushtomji, a civil servant who worked in Northeast during the turbulent years of India’s transition from a colony to a republic, recommended, these changes must be paced out so that those affected can absorb the changes without detriment to their own social organism.
Such empathetic and academically detached observations are helpful in deciphering the volatile situation in Northeast, but there also today a multiplying number of self-ordained experts who presume patronising foreknowledge of the issues in the region, spoiling the broth. Annoying paratrooping reportages of the prolonged Manipur crisis demonstrated this.
The bigger challenge however is for communities in the Northeast to introspect and come to terms with their new reality. All must change, preferably on consensually evolved terms of law that leave no party feeling a loser. Benedict Anderson’s 1983 book arguing the nation is an “imagined community”, therefore also given to reimagining, is a helpful reminder. A century before him, Ernest Renan also anticipated this necessity for change in his 1882 lecture What is a Nation where he concluded that the nation is a “daily plebiscite”.
At the time of Indian independence, upheavals broke out among many Northeast communities outraged over their traditional notions of sovereignty being overturned. Many of them hardened into violent insurgencies. After the lapse of eight decades, should it now not be time to rethink and realigned to the shifts their original targets would have undergone? Are the grievances of that era still those of the present generation?
The past is very much real. A traumatic past even more unforgettable. The important and difficult question therefore always is, how is any society with a traumatic past ever to leave it behind, without disowning it or its contributions, so that the present can to move forward unfettered.
Freud’s famous essay, Mourning & Melancholia, addresses this problem to identify two broad strategies different people use to cope with grief and loss. Some get trapped in melancholia. For they begin to take a perverse sense of gratification in their very idea of victimhood, and at pointing accusatory fingers at the perceived perpetrators of their grief.
In Freud’s mourning, loss is born differently. Unlike in melancholia, the mourner keeps the dead past and living present apart, so that the living can bid farewell and move ahead.
There have been many outstanding explorations of this psychological theme in literature and cinema. In Cathy Caruth’s collection of essays Unclaimed Experience: Trauma, Narrative and History, the one which critiques Alain Resnais’ Hiroshima Mon Amour does exactly this, Alfred Hitchcock’s Marnie, and most recently Christopher Nolan’s 2010 Hollywood hit Inception are some more prominent examples.
Inception, is illustrative. In this science fiction thriller, beyond the cinematic adventures, the protagonist is shown as burdened with guilt that the idea of a better world beyond the present that he held and communicated with his wife may have been a factor behind her suicide. He comes to be haunted by her in his dreams.
Technology is available for traveling deep into the subconscious mind through layers of dreams within dreams. The deepest is after the fourth layer, but dangerous for the dreamer may not be able to wake back to the conscious world. He does it nonetheless and meets his wife there, where he tells her he was wrong about the life beyond life, that he was sorry, and that he will love her always, but they cannot be together for she is dead and he is still alive and has to move on. That journey to the past to come to terms with a painful truth, becomes his purge.
Communities in the Northeast too must find the way to leave behind their past with disowning it, and reconcile with their present. Their targets of 80 years ago would have moved, and they must readjust aims to not be destined to always miss them.
Quite naturally, there will also be vested interests of many benefitting from the status quo as hurdles, and these too would have to be overcome. The wisdom in the thought that the Northeast too is an imagined community needing the metaphoric plebiscite periodically cannot be ignored lest the region ends up perpetually fighting symptoms of larger malaises characterised by Freud’s melancholia.
This article was first published in The New Indian Express. The original can be read HERE





